GAMES. COLLECTIBLES. BAD DECISIONS.

An independent gaming & collecting publication
Joking Joystick

Serious about games.
Not so serious about everything else.

Create accountGame guides

Explore Joking JoystickFind your next game, guide or obsession.

Keep Joking Joystick in your feed.Choose us as a preferred source on Google.

Add as a Preferred Source on Google
Subscribe via RSSAll feeds
The verdict, with context

Game reviews.
Find your next favorite.

Gameplay, atmosphere, and the details that make a game worth your time. Clear verdicts for your next adventure.

Browse reviews How to read our reviews

Unscored reviews

Follow the review feed

Reviews and assessments with a written verdict and no assigned score.

92 reviews

PCDetective adventure

Sockpuppet Noir Preview: A Hand-Filmed Detective Adventure With a Voice-Activated Twist

Sockpuppet Noir has a distinctive announced premise: a noir investigation led by Frank Sockowski and performed by filmed physical sock puppets. Its advertised loop of scene examination, interrogation, gossip, clue assembly, notes, and arrest gives the concept practical detective-game shape. The final quality of its cases, puzzles, writing, and presentation remains unverified ahead of its planned September 25, 2026 PC release.

Darryl Polo 11 min read
Read the review
PCPoint-and-click minigame anthology

The Trolley Solution PC Assessment: A Point-and-Click Anthology Built Around Ethical Absurdity

An unscored PC assessment: The Trolley Solution’s official pitch is unusually clear—a single-player, humorous anthology built from the original trolley dilemma, 20 additional variations, and 20 corresponding point-and-click minigames. It is best suited to players interested in absurd ethical-comedy prompts rather than a sustained philosophy simulation.

Darryl Polo 7 min read
Read the review
PCThird-person action adventure

1666: Amsterdam Early Access Preview: A Supernatural City With a Demanding Road Ahead

Unscored Early Access assessment: 1666: Amsterdam has a distinctive supernatural-historical premise and promising reported strengths in setting, art direction, worldbuilding, and cat-based exploration. Reports also raise build-specific concerns about combat repetition, uneven systems, and polish. Evaluate the current build rather than the planned future version.

Darryl Polo 9 min read
Read the review
PCDark-fantasy visual novel

STARCULT. Night: Twisted Age Preview: An Emotion Palette Could Give Dark-Fantasy Romance Real Consequence

STARCULT. Night: Twisted Age has a promising announced premise: an emotion palette could make romance, mystery, and horror feel more personally responsive. Early-demo evidence suggests initial intrigue and distinctive character art, but it remains too limited to establish the quality, scope, polish, or consequences of a planned multi-act release.

Darryl Polo 9 min read
Read the review
PCReal-time strategy, third-person action, RPG

WARSHIFT 2 PC Assessment: An Ambitious RTS-Action Hybrid That Depends on Clarity

WARSHIFT 2 presents a compelling but demanding hybrid: base-building and troop command are paired with direct hero control and progression in one ambitious battlefield design. Reported concerns about interface clarity, onboarding, controls, bugs, and difficulty pacing are central rather than incidental to that promise. The demo is the most sensible starting point for players drawn to its unusual mix; players seeking a conventional, polished RTS should remain cautious.

Darryl Polo 11 min read
Read the review
PCVehicular-combat shooter

Mad Metal PC Launch Assessment: Component Combat Meets an Ambitious Road Ahead

Mad Metal launches with a distinctive component-targeting combat idea and an unusually broad set of campaign, co-op, extraction, and competitive modes. Its public development history suggests sustained attention to key fundamentals, but the game’s scope makes handling, stability, mode clarity, and online population crucial open questions. It is a promising launch proposition rather than a definitive critical verdict.

Darryl Polo 10 min read
Read the review
PC2D metroidvania

Demidoff Corp Preview: Ural Folklore Meets Metroidvania Exploration

Demidoff Corp has a distinctive announced premise: Ural folk tales, a fluffy retired royal agent, and an interconnected world of estates, mines, forests and palaces. Its promise is clear, but combat feel, readability, navigation and the balance of lore, possible platforming and exploration remain unproven ahead of its public playtest.

Darryl Polo 11 min read
Read the review
A little context goes a long way

Read beyond the stars.

The version matters.

Platform and edition details appear when they are known. Check those details before applying a review to a different release.

The verdict comes first.

Stars offer a quick overview. The written verdict and scoring rationale explain who a game may suit and what may hold it back.

Know the trade-offs.

Look for what works, what gets in the way, and who the game might suit. A strong recommendation still leaves room for a different taste in games.

Our ten-star scale

Each score is an editorial assessment of the strengths and weaknesses discussed in the written review. Partial stars show decimal scores. Why this score gives the reasoning behind the rating.

9–10 stars
Outstanding. Its strengths make it an especially compelling recommendation.
7–8.9 stars
Strong. Plenty to recommend, with clear limitations to consider.
5–6.9 stars
Mixed. Worth considering for the right player, with substantial trade-offs.
3–4.9 stars
Weak. Problems frequently undermine the parts that work.
0–2.9 stars
Poor. The review describes fundamental problems that make a recommendation difficult.

These are editorial ratings. Reviews without an assigned score display their written verdict.

Our editorial standards

Your privacy settings

Make yourself at home. You can change these choices anytime using the link in our footer.

Read our privacy policy

Add to Home Screen

Use your browser’s menu to install Joking Joystick.

See all installation instructions DON’T MISS THE NEXT GOOD STORY

More of what
you love playing.

Get original gaming histories, homebrew updates and your favorite topics when they go live. You choose what reaches you.

Choose my alerts
Free. No account needed. Turn alerts off anytime.