Five members of the Cascio family and James Porte have filed a civil lawsuit against attorney Bryan Freedman in Los Angeles County Superior Court, alleging that he mishandled his role in a 2019–2020 agreement with the Michael Jackson estate.
The plaintiffs—Frank, Edward, Dominic, Aldo and Marie-Nicole Cascio, along with Porte, who is Marie-Nicole’s husband—name Freedman as the sole defendant. Their complaint alleges malpractice, breach of fiduciary duty, fraud and negligent misrepresentation. These are allegations in a newly filed civil case, not findings by a court.
At the center of the dispute is an agreement the family says was presented as a sale of rights connected to their life stories. The plaintiffs contend that Freedman was sent to negotiate on the estate’s behalf after Leaving Neverland aired in 2019, but that he told them they did not need separate counsel. They further allege he did not tell them he was working for the estate.
The suit was filed November 18. It follows a separate case brought in February by Edward, Dominic, Marie-Nicole and Aldo Cascio alleging childhood sexual abuse. That underlying case was sent to arbitration by a federal judge in August, and a joint filing dated November 10 indicated that arbitration was continuing.
What the new lawsuit alleges
The plaintiffs say five of them signed the disputed agreement in December 2019, with Frank Cascio signing in January 2020. In their account, the deal provided for five annual payments of $690,000 to each plaintiff, subject to a 6% commission.
But the financial terms are only one part of the complaint. The suit says the agreement contained a release of claims against the estate and required private arbitration. It also allegedly contained a provision under which disclosure of alleged abuse by one family member could require the entire group to return money received under the agreement.
The family’s lawyers argue that the plaintiffs would not have executed the deal had Freedman explained the implications of those provisions. The lawsuit seeks damages to be set at trial, punitive damages and attorneys’ fees.
“Had Freedman explained to Plaintiffs the implications of any of these provisions, they never would have signed the Agreement,” the plaintiffs’ lawyers wrote in the complaint.
Related coverage includes Cascio Family Sues Attorney Bryan Freedman Over Michael Jackson Estate Agreement.
The case does not name the Michael Jackson estate as a defendant. Instead, it focuses on Freedman’s alleged conduct while the agreement was being arranged and signed.
Why the alleged role conflict matters
A central question raised by the complaint is whether the plaintiffs were fully informed about whom Freedman represented. A lawyer’s relationship to a client matters because it affects whose interests the lawyer is expected to advance and what duties may be owed in the course of legal representation.
The Cascio family alleges that Freedman acted for the estate while presenting himself in a manner that caused them to proceed without independent legal advice. The complaint points to a separate court filing that shows Freedman represented Edward Cascio and Porte in a dispute involving a posthumous Jackson album. That prior representation is part of the factual backdrop the plaintiffs cite, but the new lawsuit will need to establish how Freedman’s role operated in connection with the estate agreement itself.
Malpractice generally refers to a claim that a professional failed to meet the standard of care applicable to that profession. Breach of fiduciary duty concerns an alleged failure to honor duties of loyalty, disclosure or care that can arise in a relationship of trust. Fraud and negligent misrepresentation concern claims that a party was given false or misleading information, with differing allegations about intent and carelessness.
Those definitions describe the labels in the complaint; they do not establish that the claims will succeed. The court process will determine whether the plaintiffs can prove the factual and legal elements required for each cause of action.
Arbitration and releases are key parts of the dispute
The complaint’s emphasis on arbitration and released claims explains why the precise wording of the agreement is likely to matter. Arbitration is a private dispute-resolution process in which a neutral decision-maker, rather than a judge or jury in an ordinary public courtroom case, resolves a dispute. It can be required by contract, though the enforceability and reach of arbitration provisions can be contested.
A release is a contract provision in which a person agrees to give up specified legal claims, often in exchange for payment or another benefit. The plaintiffs allege that their agreement released claims against the estate. Their position is that they were not adequately advised about what they were relinquishing.
The alleged repayment clause adds another layer. As described in the complaint, one person’s disclosure of alleged abuse could expose all signatories to an obligation to return money. The plaintiffs characterize that as a significant consequence they say was not properly explained before they signed.
Whether particular terms are enforceable, what claims they cover and whether the agreement was reached under circumstances that affect its validity are legal questions that depend on the contract language and evidence presented in the case. The new action seeks to hold Freedman responsible for the plaintiffs’ claimed losses rather than directly resolve the allegations made against the estate in the separate proceeding.
How this case relates to the separate allegations
The February lawsuit by four Cascio siblings is distinct from the new action against Freedman. The earlier case concerns alleged childhood sexual abuse; the new complaint centers on the negotiation and consequences of the estate agreement.
A federal judge sent the separate case to arbitration in August. A subsequent joint filing confirmed the process remained active as of November 10. The siblings have also discussed their underlying allegations in an interview with 60 Minutes Australia.
The estate has disputed the siblings’ allegations. Attorney Martin Singer previously characterized them as a “desperate money grab.” That is the estate’s stated position, while the allegations remain contested.
The procedural distinction is important: an arbitration order in the separate matter does not itself decide the merits of the Cascios’ allegations, nor does the filing against Freedman decide whether he committed malpractice or any other alleged wrongdoing. Each dispute has its own claims, parties and legal questions, even though both arise from the family’s history with Jackson and the estate.
What happens next
The plaintiffs are asking for compensatory damages, punitive damages and legal fees. Compensatory damages are intended to address alleged losses. Punitive damages, if available and awarded, are intended to punish particularly wrongful conduct and deter similar conduct; they are not automatic in civil cases.
Freedman had not been reached for comment at the time the lawsuit was reported. His response in court, if filed, will be important in clarifying how he characterizes his relationship with the plaintiffs, the estate and the negotiation of the agreement.
For readers following music-industry and celebrity-adjacent developments, this dispute illustrates how rights agreements can carry consequences beyond payment figures. Representation, releases, confidentiality-related terms and arbitration clauses can all define what options signatories have later. That legal backdrop sits alongside the wider cultural attention that continues to surround Jackson’s legacy and related entertainment news, including coverage of music events such as a Southern rap-focused Jazz Fest 2027 lineup.
For now, the new case remains at the allegation stage. The immediate issue is not a ruling on the underlying abuse claims, but whether the plaintiffs can show that Freedman had obligations to them, failed to disclose a conflicting role, and caused them to enter an agreement they say they would otherwise have rejected.



